My book club book was Which Witch? by Eva Ibbotson. I very much disliked this book because of the very bad ending it was a let down and very predictable.
There was nothing in the book that was good like the part when Belladonna and Terence were talking in the garden it was so boring and it went on for a really long time.
Another thing was in this really weird party seen it just made everything really depressing and sad that it was just plane boring.
The only thing that was good in the book was the wizard competition. There were some cool parts in the competition like when Madam Olimpia made rats the size of dogs, or when Belladonna brings Sir Simon back from the dead.
My advice to the author is one thing that could be better in this book. The ending could be way better. like maybe Madam Olimpia could crash the wedding maybe Madam Olimpia could turn Ariman in to a frog so Belladonna would have to fight Madam Olimpia. I did not like my book it was really boring and very dull. I give this book 1 tree
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteOwch. that sounds bad
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteEli,
ReplyDeleteYou wrote pretty detailed,
you did a the advice for the author.
Thing you need to work on
help me know what you are talking about,
try to give better word for description,
you need a conclusion.
I like the way you used detailed summary and convinced me to not read this book.I was looking forward reading it but on I AM NOT!!!
ReplyDelete